
Evening Rochester local L031 prepares to lift one covered hopper from American Packaging in Chili, NY on a muggy summer Friday night.
If you're at all familiar with my photographic musings, you might know that I have an affinity for the rarest of the rare shots, specifically pertaining to industries. For the last three years, I held Tam Ceramics in Niagara Falls as the hardest customer to shoot, only receiving a handful of two bay zircon hoppers each year. However, the last five months have proven to me there is a new champion to hold the title of least served customer in Western New York. In all of 2024 (so far), the hopper pictured here is the only railcar American Packaging has ordered at this site. There is a another more frequently served location closer to the city of Rochester, but that will be addressed momentarily. One car at a site which has a capacity for up to 12 is pretty mind-boggling, although in this economy, maybe it's not so outlandish afterall.
American Packaging Corporation started life in the early 1900s as American Bag & Paper in the city of Philadelphia, PA. It wasn't until 1966 that they expanded, with their first acquisition in Rochester, NY of the Northern Packaging company. A few short years later they purchased Ameri-Pak in Columbus, WI and by 1982 had merged to form American Pacakging Corp. It wasn't until June 2017 that they sought out and began groundbreaking for a new site in Chili, NY. With a stake in the Rochester area for 50 years at that point, it certainly made sense, not to mention dollar incentives given by the state. That location was up and running the following year in June 2018, and by mid-2019 had completed further expansion with a rail siding installed off of CSX's West Shore Subdivision which bypasses the city of Rochester. Aside from interchanging with the Livonia, Avon & Lakeville Railroad at Genesee Junction, American Pacakging is presently the only other CSX customer on the West Shore. In 2024, the company has six locations: two in Wisconsin including the former Ameri-Pak site, one in Iowa, of course the two here in New York, and their newest plant in Utah. Three of the four sites outside of New York are near rail access, however satellite views suggest that only the New York locations are rail-served at this time. It would not surprise me if the new Utah location were to join in that regard, as the surrounding rail-served industries are all in the plastics business as well.
Cars for American Packaging originate at the Dow Chemical plant in Plaquemine, LA which is a huge industrial site with its own switchers and hundreds of railcars, being filled with various products to ship out to consumers all over the country. Dow Chemical cars typically bare the reporting mark DOWX. While the plant on Beaver Rd in Chili is only a few years old, the city location has been around for decades. Located near the General Motors plant of Rochester, that one is served by the Rochester & Southern Railroad on their Belt Line, which runs north/south and also serves the Kodak Business Park among other customers. The APC plant in the city has a smaller spur which can fit up to four covered hoppers, as opposed to the two track 12 car capacity of the Chili location. It seems they are served far more frequently, anywhere from once a week to every other week. However in all my drives by, I've never observed fewer than four hoppers at full capacity there, despite the building being half the size of the Chili plant. Thankfully I documented that location last summer in 2023 with relative ease. I never imagined that the newer and bigger site would be served less than its smaller and much older counterpart, but here we are. As perplexing as it is, that is simply the reality of the situation. Funnily enough, another Rochester customer on CSX has a similar story, being outshined by its smaller twin on the DLWR in Batavia, but that's for a separate post. It's story time on how this shot came to be, and all the struggles incurred along the way.
___________________________________
March 2024. After suffering driving issues with my car throughout the month of February, all was taken care of and feeling fresh at the start of March. Spring was lurching ever closer, along with daylight savings. I made an afternoon trip out to the LA&L to document a customer no one had properly shot yet, Diamond Pacakging in Henrietta (yes, another pacakging company, but box cars instead of hoppers). Having successfully captured the shots I desired, I set off back towards home, but not without making a quick pit stop to scope out American Pacakging for the first time. My goals for 2024 were to canvas CSX ops around Rochester and the LA&L's customers. Still a work in progress admittedly, but getting closer to completion. Standing in the doorframe of my rear seats for elevation, my camera managed just enough zoom to see the car number of the lone hopper sitting there at the time. I found the best frame and saved it, then called it in on CSX TouchTrace. My jaw dropped when its status came back. It wasn't so much the fact it was still loaded, but rather that it had been placed in the middle of the night on September 26th, 2023. The car had been sitting there for nearly six months. Right away I knew this was gonna be more difficult than I was used to. I left that information alone for a week, deciding to trace it occasionally to see if and when anything would change. The timing was impeccable, as the following Monday I found out the car had been finally released as empty on Friday the same week I photographed it. Unsure of why it hadn't been picked up, I drove out that night and waited on L031 to depart Batavia towards the West Shore. On my way to the customer spur, a deer struck my car on a back road, shattering my driver side headlight and denting the fender. After checking the car briefly, I pressed on to beat the local still to the plant. Adding insult to injury, they blew right through the area, leaving me quite angry with myself and my decisions. With a rental car secured while waiting for damage evaluation the rest of the week, I went about my life again unsure of when this car would be pulled. Enlisting the help of the famous PRR hating Rodney Kantorksi, he too was unable to find the railcar or even the customer in their computers. It was a mystery for the ages. That same week, I considered on a whim driving out once more on a Friday night to see if they'd stop to work there. However, I had picked up a side gig of scorekeeping hockey games in a local league for extra cash, and I got a text asking if I could cover a game that night. With nothing planned, I said sure. Just I was about to leave the house, a friend who lives near the plant texted me saying L031 had just told dispatch they were stopping to work it that night. The week just kept getting better, as earlier that day insurance decided to total my car. (I still have the car thankfully and ended up repairing it myself.) I sat through that hockey game angry as ever, while my friend managed a phone shot of the crew pulling the single hopper. I felt defeated, but not deterred. It takes a lot to break my spirit.
Over the next three months, with the help of Rodney, he checked once a week at my request for any incoming cars for the plant, which had finally been found in the system in order to pull the car in the first place. Had it not been for me pointing it out to him, and his word passed along to the Rochester trainmaster, who knows how long the car would have sat unbothered. It seems it had been so long since they were switched that the computer purged them from the system. Nevertheless, a night in June came along unexpectedly while Rodney had been checking a different customer. He just happened to look at AP the same night and at long last another car was on the way. The joy of hearing this news was met with the realization of potentially missing it again altogether. A planned trip to Philadelphia with my best friend and his brother for a concert and weekend vacation was only a week away, and the car was estimated to arrive within the same week. Once again, impeccable timing. All along I jokingly said to myself watch the next car show up while we're in Philly. Sure enough, it was about to happen. Taking multiple 24 hour stints at three classification yards, the car made it to Rochester on a Wednesday afternoon, the day before we were to leave for vacation. Too late to make the local that night, the car sat in the yard for the next two days. TouchTrace even updated its scheduled placement from that Wednesday to Friday. With the concert also being on Friday, I said forget about it and enjoyed our trip. Following the concert and getting back to the hotel that night, I once again traced the car with my heart pounding, and again to my surprise the car had not even departed that night. I found out L031 had been annulled for the evening, leaving the car to again sit till Monday, when we would be back home. Although in that moment I rejoiced, the remainder of the Philly trip was plagued with nothing but adversity, suffering two separate car repairs and almost being stranded without a way home. Thankfully everything worked out last minute and we were back home late Sunday night. Utilizing the 511NY traffic cameras, after hearing L031 call to depart Monday evening, I watched the train pass above I-490 from my best friend's house before setting off for Batavia again. Having formally met the crew in the prior weeks of shooting them, at least this time I wouldn't be going in as a stranger. Indeed the hopper was on the train that night, with Rochester electing not to run an extra over the weekend. The first big caveat though was given how big the train was, they were using three engines, which would all be long hood for the shot. The next caveat came in Batavia, as the crew sat for hours due to one of the engines experiencing failure when getting ready to head for the West Shore. I watched the Florida Panthers secure their Game 7 Stanley Cup victory against the Edmonton Oilers in my car while I waited. Around midnight the flying squad made an appearance at Batavia yard to troubleshoot the engine. They got moving again close to 1:00 a.m. With one of the main tracks shut down through Rochester that night, there was a lot more traffic taking the West Shore than usual, forcing L031 to wait even longer for their window to work. I considered going home, but still stuck with it. After everything I'd been through up to that point, I couldn't throw in the towel. Part of me hoped maybe they'd tie down in Batavia and leave it to the morning crew, but they did eventually get their signal. It was now 3:00 a.m., and I was standing at the switch into American Pacakging awaiting their arrival. I made sure the engineer Doug knew I was there, along with his conductor and their trainee, who must've thought I was insane. Imagine training for a future on the railroad, and a random photographer is out at the most obscure industry in the middle of the night, to watch you help spot "the one car a year this place gets," as joked by the conductor Tony. As you can clearly see, this is not the shot I got that night. The three engines made the situation less than ideal. It was a start, but ultimately it ended up being a practice shot for the real thing.
It's now the middle of August. Based on the previous hopper's demurrage time, I estimated this one might be released some time around Christmas. Still though, I was diligent and checked its status on the days L031 goes down the Shore (M/W/F). On a Friday morning, the car traced as empty and released. I couldn't believe it. I texted Rodney, and my friend Cooper who had connections with L031's crew, the same friend who got the phone shot in March. Rodney had no straight answer for me if they'd pick it up, but Cooper got a response thankfully which pointed to them likely working there that night. My concern was if would it make their paperwork in time. Sure enough it did. Just like in June, I was again at my best friend's house briefly before L031 called to leave. Watching the cam once more, this time it was one engine and eight cars. Still would be long hood for the shot, but one unit was way better than three. Of note, Cooper's phone shot featured a proper facing engine, which also is hard to come by as most of the time engines face west in Rochester. Regardless, I set out for Batavia just like before, this time making a point to chat with the crew there to make sure they were stopping that night. They confirmed it, and I made my way out early. Cooper was able to join this time as well, having just gotten out of work nearby the plant, equipped with a proper camera this go around. I think I fired off over 50 something shots that night, trying a couple different angles. The ambient lighting was plentiful this time with the main engine much closer to the car and building. To say I'm relieved would be an understatement, but having finally checked this shot off is a huge weight off my shoulders in the topsy-turvy year that has been 2024. I'm hoping my next obsession won't be so costly, time consuming, and stress inducing as this one was, but man oh man does it take the cake. It may very well be my favorite shot of the year, though there's still quite a bit of year left to go. Out of the numerous customers I've shot, if this doesn't deserve the number one spot, it's at least in the top five for difficulty no doubt. Cheers to the next great mystery waiting to be uncovered.