This was a good time of day to be looking at this, because the shadow across the right edge of the datestone distracts us from noticing that the 1909 is badly off-center.
It is apparent that "EST. 1874" was engraved sometime much later than 1909, possibly driven by a bee-bonnet congregant all wound up that the datestone was installed in reference to the church as a building and not as an institution. Maybe it happened circa 1974.
-----------------------
In Neenah, Wisconsin, on May 22nd, 2024, was a datestone at the Immanuel United Church of Christ (historically a Lutheran church) at the northeast corner of Oak Street and East Doty Street. The church closed in December 2024.
-----------------------
Getty Thesaurus of Geographic Names terms:
• Neenah (7014194)
• Winnebago (county) (2002363)
Art & Architecture Thesaurus terms:
• building stone (300011700)
• churches (buildings) (300007466)
• churches (institutions) (300312247)
• date stones (300374978)
• doorways (300002767)
• engraving (action) (300053829)
• establishment (action or condition) (300393212)
• Lutheran (300153842)
• yellow brick (material) (300444206)
Wikidata items:
• 22 May 2024 (Q69307176)
• 1874 in religion (Q123371365)
• 1900s in architecture (Q16482507)
• 1909 in architecture (Q2811101)
• 2024 in religion (Q123832455)
• Appleton-Oshkosh-Neenah, WI Combined Statistical Area (Q126130444)
• Cream City brick (Q5183349)
• Evangelical and Reformed Church (Q5415769)
• Fox Cities (Q5476644)
• Fox Valley (Q126146595)
• International Symbol of Access (Q2326276)
• May 22 (Q2581)
• May 2024 (Q61312957)
• Treaty of the Cedars (Q7837316)
• United Church of Christ (Q426316)
Library of Congress Subject Headings:
• Lutheran church buildings (sh85025871)